“买它!”中的规训力量——基于对网络直播间话语分析的案例研究

高应蓓, 刘书博

中央财经大学学报 ›› 2022, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (12) : 134-147.

PDF(1395 KB)
PDF(1395 KB)
中央财经大学学报 ›› 2022, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (12) : 134-147.
案例研究

“买它!”中的规训力量——基于对网络直播间话语分析的案例研究

  • 高应蓓, 刘书博
作者信息 +

“Just Buy It!”The Discipling Force of Online Marketing: Discourse Analysis on Online Living Broadcasting

  • GAO Ying-bei, LIU Shu-bo
Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

电商直播是近年来中国消费市场快速崛起的领域,通过淘宝等直播平台,消费活动被带入了快车道,通过主播富有感染性的表达,一种新的消费氛围和场景被构建出来。网络直播如何通过话语来促进消费者购买?本文以福柯的规训理论视角,应用话语分析方法来探究直播间话语的构建特色,揭露出不同类型话语的功能:关系互动话语和关联构建话语构建了消费场景,信息提供话语制造了景观,符号话语和身份话语形成了纪律和指令。同时,基于对直播间话语受众的访谈进行互动话语分析,进一步呈现出直播间话语对消费行为的影响。研究发现,直播平台中的话语具有开放的双向沟通特色,但在这看似自由的“直播间共同体”中,消费者的主体性被消费主义所规训,消费者在互动交流和更为开放的消费场景中反而进一步丧失了主体性地位。   

Abstract

From the perspective of Foucault's discipline theory, this paper explores how Taobao Live Room, a new online market, builds identity and rules through discourse, creating scene atmosphere, building consumption scenes and stimulates consumption demand, thus opening up a huge consumption market.At the same time, through interviews with the audience in the live broadcast room, we can understand their views and feelings and conduct interactive research.It is found that this seemingly democratic and fair two-way marketing platform is actually more consumerist, and people's subjectivity is further constrained and disciplined by consumerism discourse.

关键词

网络直播 / 话语分析 / 消费场景 / 规训

Key words

Live broadcast / Discourse analysis / Consumption site / Disciplining

引用本文

导出引用
高应蓓, 刘书博. “买它!”中的规训力量——基于对网络直播间话语分析的案例研究[J]. 中央财经大学学报, 2022, 0(12): 134-147
GAO Ying-bei, LIU Shu-bo. “Just Buy It!”The Discipling Force of Online Marketing: Discourse Analysis on Online Living Broadcasting[J]. Journal of Central University of Finance & Economics, 2022, 0(12): 134-147
中图分类号: C93   

参考文献

[1] 陈伟军.网络直播的日常展演与场景魅惑[J].新闻与传播评论(辑刊),2019(4):54-63.
[2] 陈瑞,张晏宁,吴胜涛.直播营销模式的深层逻辑——社交场和营销场及其协同作用[J].清华管理评论,2020(12):44-52.
[3] 程灏.直播带货的符号学解读——以“谢谢你为湖北拼单”为例[J].新媒体研究,2020(14):61-62,75.
[4] 张楠楠.电商直播营销话语分析——以淘宝网为例[J].新媒体研究,2020(15):62-64.
[5] 杨楠.网红直播带货对消费者品牌态度影响机制研究[J].中央财经大学学报,2021(2):118-128.
[6] 许成龙.主流媒体与网络媒体语言传播的“融合”——以“小朱配琦”为例[J].青年记者,2020(35):61-62.
[7] 李彦迪.语域理论视角下电商主播言语社区语言特征探析——以淘宝主播薇娅和李佳琦为例[J].视听,2021(2):117-118.
[8] 罗然然.“规训式”师生关系的在场与超越——基于福柯规训理论的师生关系研究[J].渭南师范学院学报,2016(18):22-27.
[9] 米歇尔·福柯.规训与惩罚 监狱的诞生[M].刘北成,杨远婴,译.北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店,2012:155.
[10] 尼尔·波兹曼.技术垄断文明向技术投降[M].蔡金栋,等译.北京:机械工业出版社,2013:114.
[11] 詹姆斯·保罗·吉,话语分析导论理论与方法[M].杨炳钧,译.重庆:重庆大学出版社,2011:103.
[12] 谢立中.多元话语分析:社会分析模式的新尝试[J].社会,2010(2):1-19.
[13] Williamson,Judith.Decoding Advertisements[M].London: Marion Boyars Publishers,1981:72.
[14] Geertz C.The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays[M].New York: Basic Books,1973:63.
[15] 管颖华.电视购物直播节目中消费需求的营造[J].电视指南,2018(6):44.
[16] 姚力文,段峰峰.网络短视频平台流量变现探析[J].新闻前哨,2019(8):34-36.
[17] 成也,王锐.网络直播平台的治理机制——基于双边平台视角的案例研究[J].管理案例研究与评论,2017(4):355-363.
[18] Bauman Z,Liquid Modernity[M].Cambridge:Polity Press,2000: 94-103.
[19] Goffman E,Relations in Public[M].London:Allen Lane,1971:122.
[20] Storey J,Culture Studies and the Study of Popular Culture[M].Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press Ltd.,1996: 115-126.
[21] 燕道成,李菲.场景·符号·权力:电商直播的视觉景观与价值反思[J].现代传播-中国传媒大学学报,2020(6):124-129.
[22] 姚林青,顾恩澍.短视频电商模式的演进机理研究[J].现代传播—中国传媒大学学报,2021(1):123-128.
[23] 王艳玲,刘可.网络直播的共鸣效应:群体孤独·虚拟情感·消费认同[J].现代传播—中国传媒大学学报,2019(10):26-29.
[24] 蒋建国.论网络消费文化的特征[J].贵州社会科学,2010(12):49-52.
[25] Elliot R.Discourse Analysis: Exploring Action, Function and Conflict in Social Texts[J].Marketing Intelligence & Planning,1996,6(14):65-68.
[26] Hardy C.Researching Organizational Discourse[J].International Studies of Management and Organization,2001.31(3):25-47.
[27] Peng C, Liu S,Lu Y.The Discursive Strategy of Legitimacy Management: A Comparative Case Study of Google and Apple's Crisis Communication Statements[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 2021.38(2): 519-545.
[28] 丹尼尔·卡尼曼.思考,快与慢[M].胡晓姣,李爱民,何梦莹,译.北京:中信出版社,2012: 79.
[29] Creswell J W, Miller D L.Determining Validity in QualitativeInquiry[J].Theory Into Practice,2000,39(3):1-130.
[30] Lincoln Y S,Guba E G.Naturalistic Inquiry[M].Sage Publications,1985: 29-32.
[31] Lather P.Fertile Obsession: Validity After Poststructuralism[J].Sociological Quarterly,1993,4(4):673-693.
[32] Richardson L.Writing: A Method of Inquiry[J].Collecting and Interpreting Qualitative Materials (3rd ed.),2008:473-499.
[33] Green J,Thorogood N.Qualitative Methods for Health Research[M].Sage Publications,2004:25-29.
[34] Gaskell G.Individual and Group Interviewing[M] //Bauer M,Gaskell G.Qualitative Researching with Text, Image and Sound.London: Sage, 2000:42-47.
[35] Caelli K,Ray L,Mill J.“Clear as Mud”: Toward Greater Clarity in Generic Qualitative Research[J].International Journal of Qualitative Methods,2003,2(2):1-13.
[36] Glaser B G,Strauss A L.The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies For Qualitative Research[J].Nursing Research.1967, 3(2):364.
[37] O'Reilly M,Parker N.“Unsatisfactory Saturation”: A Critical Exploration of the Notion of Saturated Sample Sizes in Qualitative Research.[J].Qualitative Research,2013,13(2):190-197.

基金

国家。
PDF(1395 KB)

162

Accesses

0

Citation

Detail

段落导航
相关文章

/