近年来,基金中基金(FOF)在我国发展如火如荼,但其理论研究发展却相对滞后。加强FOF理论研究,对提升业内资产管理绩效能力和帮助学术界提出有效的资产定价及配置模型与理论具有十分重要的意义,也将有较大可能成为今后的研究热点。笔者梳理了国内外学者近年来关于FOF的基本概念、运营理论、实证分析等方面的文献以及对其双重收费等争议问题的研究进展,并尝试对FOF的业绩评价方法和指标进行了总结和分类,为业内投资者和研究者们整理了一个较为系统的FOF理论研究框架和业绩评价指标体系。这些理论和评价指标虽然未必能直接用于国内FOF市场,但我国学者可以在借鉴和吸收国内外已有研究成果的基础上,结合国内FOF市场的实际状况,进一步拓展完善FOF理论体系。笔者在总结FOF研究理论体系发展进展的基础上,进一步提出了当前研究存在的问题及今后完善和发展的方向。
Abstract
In recent years,Fund of Funds(FOF)develops vigorously in China,but development of theoretical research on FOF is relative lagged.To strengthen FOF theory research is very important to promote the industry asset management performance ability and help the academic circle put forward the effective asset pricing and configuration model and theory,it may become the research hotspot in the future.We check the domestic and foreign scholars' literature about FOF,operation theory and empirical analysis in recent years and the research progress about the dispute issues,such as rationality of Double Fee of FOF.We also summarize and classify FOF performance evaluation methods and indexes,and settle a systematic FOF theory research framework and performance evaluation index system for the investors and researchers in the industry.Although these theories and evaluation indexes may not be applied in the domestic FOF market directly,Chinese scholars can expand and perfect FOF theory systems further on the basis of referring and absorbing the domestic and foreign existed research achievements and in the combination of the actual situation of domestic FOF market.We further put forward the current existing problems of research and the future perfection and development direction based on summarizing the development progress of FOF research theory system.
关键词
基金中基金 /
运营理论 /
绩效评价 /
实证分析 /
研究进展
{{custom_keyword}} /
Key words
Fund of funds /
Operation theory /
Performance evaluation /
Empirical analysis /
Research progress
{{custom_keyword}} /
中图分类号：
F830.91 F831.2
{{custom_clc.code}}
({{custom_clc.text}})
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
参考文献
[1] 李洋,张敏.FOF基金的配置贯彻投资始终[N].中国证券报,2017-01-16.
[2] 中国证监会.公开募集证券投资基金运作指引第2号——基金中基金指引[A].中华人民共和国国务院公报,2017.
[3] 托马斯·梅耶尔,皮埃尔·依维斯·马森内特.超越J曲线[M].程凤朝,等译.北京:经济科学出版社,2008.
[4] 何小锋.FOF在中国有巨大的发展前景[J].资本市场,2010(7):104-104.
[5] 何小锋,胡渊.金融机构投资私募股权“基金的基金”——基于案例的研究[J].改革与战略,2008,24(12):61-66.
[6] 何金平.详解FOF基金的四种运作模式[J/OL].(2014-08-07)[2019-01-10] .http://funds.hexun.com/2014-08-07/167326800.html.
[7] 秋俭.FOF的发展及其对ETF的带动[N].中国证券报,2018-03-15.
[8] 董明璐.FOF在中国——后金融危机时代背景下的挑战与机遇[J].经济视角(下旬刊),2010(11):71-72.
[9] 禹久泓,杨逸青.构建公共财政作为私募股权基金母基金的框架[J].财政研究,2009(2):48-50.
[10] 黄嵩,何小锋,谢海闻,等.政府财政投资新途径:私募股权基金的基金[J].长白学刊,2011(1):114-117.
[11] 周丹.私募股权投资基金的主要组织形式:有限合伙制研究[D].北京大学,2007.
[12] 徐建军.FOF的海外发展及实践[J].中国金融,2014(4):88-89.
[13] 肖星池,冉博文,吕斓琪,等.中美FOF发展对比分析及对中国的启示[J].现代经济信息,2016(7):141-143.
[14] 宋江立.我国公募FOF的发展及应用研究[J].现代管理科学,2018,303(6):38-40,68.
[15] Ang A,Zhao R,Rhodes-Kropf M.Do Funds-of-Funds Deserve Their Fees-on-Fees?[J].Social Science Electronic Publishing,2005,6(4):22.
[16] 何剑波.智能投顾与FOF本质一致,将进一步平滑收益和风险[J/OL].(2017-07-27)[2019-01-10] .http://fund.jrj.com.cn/2017/07/27153522806785.shtml.
[17] 王德英.FOF跟智能投顾本质上是一回事,追求的目(标)一样[J/OL].(2018-02-02)[2019-01-10] .http://m.jrj.com.cn/rss/wifi/2018/2/2/24053745.shtml.
[18] 夏淳淳.美国FOF发展轨迹及配置策略分析[N].期货日报,2017-03-31.
[19] 丁鹏.FOF组合基金[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2017.
[20] 巴曙松,白海峰.多管理人基金(FOF/MOM)投资模式与金融科技应用展望[J].清华金融评论,2017(5):89-92.
[21] 马永谙.FOF管理手册[M].沈阳:沈阳出版社,2014.
[22] Weidig T,Kemmerer A,Born B.The Risk Profile of Private Equity Fund-of-Funds[J].The Journal of Alternative Investments,2004,7(4):935-944.
[23] Wolf M,Wunderli D.Fund-of-Funds Construction by Statistical Multiple Testing Methods[J].SSRN Electronic Journal,2011.
[24] Brown S,Gregoriou G,Pascalau R.Diversification in Funds of Hedge Funds:Is It Possible to Overdiversify?[J].Review of Asset Pricing Studies,2012,2:89-110.
[25] Harris R S,Jenkinson,Kaplan S N,Ruediger Stucke.Financial Intermediation in Private Equity:How Well Do Funds of Funds Perform?[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2018,4(13):1016.
[26] Aiken A L,Clifford C P,Ellis J.The Value of Funds of Hedge Funds:Evidence from Their Holdings[J].Social Science Electronic Publishing,2015,61(10):2415-2429.
[27] Gao C,Haight T,Yin C.Fund Selection,Style Allocation,and Active Management Abilities:Evidence from Funds of Hedge Funds' Holdings[J].Social Science Electronic Publishing,2017.
[28] Amin G S,Kat H M.Hedge Fund Performance 1990—2000:Do the ‘Money Machines’ Really Add Value?[J].The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,2003,38(2):251-274.
[29] Liang B.On the Performance of Alternative Investments:CTAs,Hedge Funds,and Funds-of-Funds[J].Social Science Electronic Publishing,2004,3(4):76-93.
[30] Brown S J,Goetzmann W N,Liang B.Fees on Fees in Funds of Funds[J].Journal of Investment Management,2004(2):39-56.
[31] Agarwal V,Nada V,Ray S.Institutional Investment and Intermediation in the Hedge Fund Industry[Z].Cfr Working Papers,2013,191(11):5702-5713.
[32] Treynor J L, Mazuy K K.Can Mutual Fund Outgoes the Market?[J].Harvard Business Review,1966(44):131-136.
[33] Henriksson D R,Merton R C.On Market Timing and Investment Performance.II.Statistical Procedures for Evaluating Forecasting Skills[J].The Journal of Business,1981,54(4):513-533.
[34] Keating C,Shadwick W F.A Universal Performance Measure[J].Journal of Performance Measurement,2002(6):59-84.
[35] Fama E F.Components of Investment Performance[J].Journal of Finance,1972(27):551-567.
[36] Brinson G P,Beebower G L.Determinants of Portfolio Performance[J].Financial Analysts Journal,1986,42(4):39-44.
[37] Ibbotson R G,Kaplan P D.Does Asset Allocation Policy Explain 40,90,or 100 Percent of Performance?[J].Financial Analysts Journal,2000,56(1):26-33.
[38] Kaplan S N,Schoar A.Private Equity Performance:Returns,Persistence,and Capital Flows[J].Journal of Finance,2005,60(4):1791-1823.
[39] 于丽敏.FOF择时能力评价研究[J].商业经济研究,2012(1):66-67.
[40] Brands S,Gallagher D R.Portfolio Selection,Diversification and Fund-of-funds:A Note[J].Accounting &Finace,2014,45(2):185-197.
[41] Conlon T,Ruskin H J,Crane M.Random Matrix Theory and Fund of Funds Portfolio Optimisation[J].Physical A Statistical Mechanics & Its Applications,2007,382(2):565-576.
[42] Agarwal V,Aragon G O,Shi Z.Funding Liquidity Risk of Funds of Hedge Funds:Evidence from Their Holdings[Z].Cfr Working Papers,2015.
[43] 庞华玮.FOF基金危机:规模大缩水 养老产品救场,2019表现可期[N].21世纪经济报道,2019-01-15.
[44] 李勇.FOF的投资体系[J/OL].(2017-04-18)[2019-01-10] .https://www.sohu.com/a/135057555_509997.
[45] 徐文擎.丁鹏:未来FOF领域“得体系者得天下”[N].中国证券报,2017-03-27.
[46] 郝鹏.基金公司布局FOF产品的战略研究[J].特区经济,2014(8):122-126.
[47] 张奇阳.论我国私募股权基金的法律监管——以中美比较为视角[J].法制与经济,2015(4):43-45.
{{custom_fnGroup.title_cn}}
脚注
{{custom_fn.content}}
基金
教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目“建设现代化经济体系的路径与策略研究”(项目编号:18JZD029)。
{{custom_fund}}
PDF(1207 KB)
